The four novellas that make up Old New York each take place in a different decade of the nineteenth century. “False Dawn (The ’Forties)” tells of young man, Lewis Raycie, sent to Italy by his father to purchase paintings, who ends up meeting John Ruskin and ends up buying paintings his father does not approve of. “The Old Maid (The ’Fifties)” examines two cousins, one of whom is secretly an unwed mother. “The Spark (The ’Sixties)” is about a man’s brief meeting with Walt Whitman. “She was bad…always,” begins “New Year’s Day (The ’Seventies)” and proceeds to tell how Mrs. Hazeldean got that reputation.
Published in May 1924